Close Button
Buckingham Nicks - Buckingham Nicks
Album Comparisons: Buckingham Nicks
NOTE: A comparison of the original LP release to the earlier, unofficial (bootleg) CD release can be read here.
Probably best known as the album that got Lindsey Buckingham and Stevie Nicks the Fleetwood Mac gig, this low-key release was the first recorded outing for a couple of then unknowns who somehow convinced a record label to record and release their commercial debut. Buckingham Nicks features ten songs which range stylistically from ballad to uptempo to showcasing a blistering guitar solo. It was that blistering guitar solo on the album's final track, "Frozen Love," that impressed Mick Fleetwood enough for him to extend invitations to both the guitarist Lindsey Buckingham and his partner Stevie Nicks to join his band. Although Buckingham Nicks would see multiple repressings once its creators had joined their new outfit, it eventually went out of print and existed on CD only via bootlegs until 2025, when premier reissue label Rhino Records finally brought it back to market in a legitimate digital format. Given the unfortunate tendency of reissues of classic material to err greatly on the side of overly loud remastering, how does the Rhino disc compare to the original vinyl?

Crying in the Night

1973 Polydor LP

Crying in the Night

2025 Rhino CD release

Crying in the Night

Stephanie

1973 Polydor LP

Stephanie

2025 Rhino CD release

Stephanie

Without a Leg to Stand On

1973 Polydor LP

Without a Leg to Stand On

2025 Rhino CD release

Without a Leg to Stand On

Crystal

1973 Polydor LP

Crystal

2025 Rhino CD release

Crystal

Long Distance Winner

1973 Polydor LP

Long Distance Winner

2025 Rhino CD release

Long Distance Winner

Don't Let Me Down Again

1973 Polydor LP

Don't Let Me Down Again

2025 Rhino CD release

Don't Let Me Down Again

Django

1973 Polydor LP

Django

2025 Rhino CD release

Django

Races Are Run

1973 Polydor LP

Races Are Run

2025 Rhino CD release

Races Are Run

Lola (My Love)

1973 Polydor LP

Lola (My Love)

2025 Rhino CD release

Lola (My Love)

Frozen Love

1973 Polydor LP

Frozen Love

2025 Rhino CD release

Frozen Love
And the winner is: 2025 Rhino CD release. As is plainly evident from the preceding waveforms, the compact disc release honors the original album both in audio clarity and via its complete lack of dynamic range compression. Such a feat is sadly a rarity in this day and age of digitally brickwalled remasters, but, along with some other recent reissues of classic material, this offering suggests that there may be some hope for the future.